10 Best Eyebrow Pencils for Over 60 to Enhance Mature Brows

The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the
editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product
research & curation process

Having the best eyebrow pencil for over 60 is like finding the holy grail makeup tool for women with mature skin. Eyebrows that are finely shaped and filled, while looking natural, are the ultimate goal of any makeup lover or anyone who aims to enhance their prominent features. Oftentimes, perfect brows, a little mascara, and a swift glide of tip tint are enough to completely change your look. 

With growing age, our hair tends to fall off, be it the mane or the brows. However, creating a fuller brow look is an effortless job — all you need is the right eyebrow pencil with a precise artistic tip to draw hair, the right shade to match the natural look, and a rich pigment to last for long hours. Keep scrolling to check out our favorite picks of eyebrow pencils that help create voluminous, fuller, and plush brows for mature skin on the go.

10 Best Eyebrow Pencils for Over 60 to Get Fuller Brows That Stay Put

To achieve the perfect and natural eyebrow look, L’oreal Paris’s Brow Stylist eyebrow pencil just might be your best pal. This self-sharpening mechanical pencil is beginner friendly and the ultra-fine tip effortlessly fills all the gaps and adds a matte finish, giving you flawless eyebrows. It also comes with a built-in spoolie that adds more definition and helps you blend like a professional. The waterproof formula stays put so you can go on with your day worry-free.

Etude’s Drawing Eyebrow pencil’s formula of high-adhesion plate powder, wax, and oil is the perfect combination for your eyebrows to look perfectly shaped all day long. Its triangular-shaped tip glides like butter to fill the gaps and create natural hair-like strokes. The pencil is pigmented just right to provide you with natural color and a neat finish for the ultimate polished eyebrows look. With this pencil, you never have to be concerned about over-filling your brows!

All your eyebrow worries can come to an end with NYX professional’s Precision eyebrow pencil. Its two-in-one pencil has a flat tip on one side that slides smoothly for you to create natural, hair-like strokes. You can now outline with precision and fill in the sparse spaces with precision. The other edge has a built-in spoolie that flawlessly blends everything together and combs out the hair, giving you the ‘effortless eyebrows’ look. And this product being cruelty-free is just another desirable feature.

This budget-friendly eyebrow pencil by Bodermincer is a must-have for those looking for a long-lasting and waterproof product without burning a hole in your pocket. Its smooth tip dispenses the color evenly and fills the scanty areas with ease and precision. It comes in 5 shades so you don’t have to compromise with finding the shade that suits you the best. Its waterproof formula helps the product stay on the skin and not smear. The spoolie brush at the other end is a bonus that gives your eyebrows the finishing touch it deserves!

For those looking for something that draws hair-like strokes with minimal effort, this eyebrow pen from iMethod Beauty is for you. Its tint fork tip is perfect to create accurate, fine lines that imitate natural human hair. Its effortless design is easy to use and leaves you with natural and fresh-looking eyebrows. The waterproof formula makes it smudge-free so you can have perfect eyebrows all day long, regardless of the weather. Also, this product is vegan and cruelty-free!

Like an eyebrow tattoo for older ladies, the  Maybelline’s Tattoo Studio pencil is the ideal buy for your eyebrows and pockets. This chic-looking pencil helps you achieve a seamless natural eyebrow look that stays put for up to 36 hours. It creates outlines and helps fill the needed area with precision. Its spoolie on the other side softens all the harsh lines and provides a well-blended and clean look. It features 6 shades that are inclusive of all skin and hair colors!

This chic eyebrow pencil is the perfect tool for you to create chic eyebrows. Benefit’s precise brow pencil comes with a fine tip to provide accurate and natural-looking strokes. Its pigmented formula adds depth and definition to all kinds of eyebrows and stays on for 12 hours. It features a spoolie on the other end so that you can blend with ease and precision leaving no scope for rigid lines.

Whipped to perfection, Bobby Brown’s long-wear brow pencil is a must-have. Its tip is shaped perfectly — the chiseled edge provides you with the most natural strokes, and its flat edge enables the flawless filling of scant spaces. It is pigmented correctly so that your brows look effortless all day long. It also comes with a spoolie to even out the color and comb the eyebrow hair for a clean look. Another charm of this product is, it can be refilled again at your ease with replaceable pencil cartridges. 

MAC’s Lingering brow pencil undoubtedly deserves a spot on your makeup shelf — its self-sharpening and fine tip mimics hair-like strokes with ease giving your eyebrows a minimal and polished look. It is perfect to outline your brows or make them look fuller or just add a little color. Its pen-like application will make you feel like a professional while beautifying your eyebrows. It also lasts long, making your eyebrows look naturally dense all day long!

The perfect tip of Artdeco’s eyebrow pencil is neither too soft nor too hard making it a suitable and easy-to-use brow pencil for beginners. Its tip is fine and precise to create hair-like strokes and fill all the unwanted gaps. It is also long-lasting so you can trust it for not smearing readily, preserving the natural look round the clock. This product is a great companion for creating those seamless eyebrows!

How to Choose an Eyebrow Pencil for Over 60?

Usage: With the advancement of age, our brow hair fades and begins falling out from the tail. There are more grey hair and the shape of the brows gets slimmer. Based on your usage and preference, it is highly essential to pick the right tool to cater to your goals. 

• For covering your salt-n-pepper brows, opt for a richly pigmented pencil that effectively dispenses color tints on the hair. Make sure you pick a shade that matches your skin tone and is close to your real brow hair color. 
• If your goal is to lock the brow art for long hours, peruse the product label to purchase a waterproof, smudge-proof, and sweat-proof, offering transfer-resistant, lasting wear. 
• In case your brows are scanty and need precise strokes to draw fine hair, look for a pigmented micro tip that gives a natural finish post-application.

Ingredients: With growing age, the skin ages too, especially the area around the eyes which is sensitive in nature. To prevent any skin irritation, skin damage, or hair shedding, avoid parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and sulfites.

How to Use an Eyebrow Pencil for Over 60?

To create brows that are well-defined, perfectly shade-matched, and with a hair-like natural finish, follow these simple steps:

Step 1: Make sure your brows are clean and well combed with a spoolie brush. You can do your brows before the makeup, in between, or make it a finishing step in your regime. 

Step 2: Next, gently draw the brow shape for a well-defined look. You can directly jump to the third step if you are more into a raw, brushed look.

Step 3: Begin drawing fine hair-like strokes that are short and well-blended. Make sure to go in the direction of your natural flow and fill all the sparse gaps.

Pro hack: To seal the brows and add more dimension, use brow mascara to brush over the brow hair for a mildly laminated finish. 

The best eyebrow pencil for over 60 can promise to be a simple yet effective tool that allows you to draw, shape, and fill brows with hair-like strokes. Available in various shades, pigments, and tip shapes that match all hair colors and skin tones, brow definer pencils are a great addition to the makeup vanity of mature women. Women love their brows and value them preciously, as they play an extremely essential role in defining the countenance and complementing their facial features. To regain your desirable eyebrows and confidence, trust the makeup tools that can help you achieve your beauty goals.